Consider a common situation here in the Northland: parents own a family cabin and have three adult children. The family spent many summer weekends swimming, boating, fishing, and enjoying everything lake life has to offer. Parent’s estate plan leaves the cabin to the children in equal shares. The parents view this as the fairest approach because the cabin has substantial monetary and sentimental value and assume the children will continue enjoying the property together for years to come.
After the parents’ deaths, however, the children discover that they all have very different expectations. Anna, the oldest, lives nearby and uses the cabin regularly. She also handles most of the upkeep and repair costs. Ben, the middle child, lives several hours away and visits less frequently, but he feels strongly that the cabin should remain in the family. Claire, the youngest,lives out of state and rarely visits. She has her own mortgage and does not want to contribute thousands of dollars each year toward a property she may use for only one weekend per year.
The differences in expectations become more pronounced when the cabin needs a new roof. Anna wants the siblings to divide the cost equally. Ben agrees that the work is necessary but cannot immediately pay his share. Claire does not want to contribute at all and wants to be bought out of her interest.
An Equal Inheritance
Under Minnesota Statutes 500.19, subd. 2, a devise of real estate to two or more people generally creates a tenancy in common unless the conveyance instrument (i.e., deed) expressly creates a joint tenancy. In this situation, the Transfer on Death Deed that the parents used to devise the cabin to children did not expressly create a joint tenancy, thus Anna, Ben, and Claire are each anowner of an undivided one-third interest in the cabin as tenants in common. That does not mean each child owns a particular one-third portion of the property; rather, each sibling has a one-third ownership interest in the entire cabin.
On paper, the arrangement appears straightforward. Each child received one-third of a valuable family asset, and no one was favored over anyone else. The estate plan answered the questionabout “who gets the cabin?” but it did not answer, “how will three people own it together?”
When Equal Is Not Fair
The default rules governing a tenancy in common ownership arrangement provide each sibling with a right to possess the property and make each sibling responsible for their proportionate share of necessary expenses. However, these rules are not common knowledge and do not provide the family with a complete operating plan. They do not decide who receives Fourth of July weekend, establish a process for approving and paying expenses, or determine how to treat optional improvements.
Each sibling’s view of fairness may be perfectly reasonable. Anna may believe that her time and labor should reduce her share of the expenses. Ben may want to preserve the cabin but lacks the cash to pay for a major repair. Claire may conclude that continued ownership does not fit her life.
A tenancy in common also creates issues beyond annual expenses and holiday schedules. A co-owner generally may transfer their ownership interest without the consent of the other co-owners. As a result, the siblings could eventually find themselves owning the cabin with an in-law, a creditor, a third-party purchaser, or someone else the parents never intended to include.
Planning Before the Cabin Passes
The most valuable planning step may also be the simplest: parents should talk with their children. Before leaving the cabin equally to everyone, parents should ask who wants it, who expects to use it, and who can reasonably afford to maintain it.
If only one or two children want the cabin, the estate plan can reflect that reality. Interested children might receive an option to purchase the interests of their siblings or the entire interest in the cabin out of their distributive share of the estate. A right of first refusal could also give children an opportunity to purchase an interest before it is transferred outside the family. Any such provision should address valuation, deadlines, contingencies, and payment terms.
Families may also consider placing the cabin in a trust or limited liability company. With a cabin trust, the trust owns the property, and the trustee administers it under written terms given by the settlors (creators) of the trust. Those terms can address use, expenses, management, transfers, succession, and an eventual sale. With an LLC, the company owns the cabin and the family members own membership interests in the company. An operating agreement, the governing document for an LLC, can establish voting rights, financial obligations, transfer restrictions, buyout procedures, and rules governing who may become a future owner.
Creating a Plan After the Fact
Parents did not set up a trust or an LLC. However, Anna, Ben, and Claire can still create rules and procedures for their tenancy in common after the fact. After discussing their different expectations, the siblings entered into a co-tenancy agreement. The agreement established how they would divide taxes, expenses, and maintenance responsibilities. It established a process for creating an annual usage calendar and rules for guests and rentals. It distinguished between routine and major decisions and established the votes required for each.
Most importantly, the co-tenancy agreement created an exit procedure. If one sibling wanted to leave, the others would receive an opportunity to purchase that interest. The cabin’s value would be determined through an appraisal process, and the purchasing siblings could make payments over a specified period. If no one could complete the buyout, the agreement provided a process for selling the property on the open market.
Finally, the agreement addressed what would happen when a sibling died and whether a spouse, child, or other successor could become an owner. The agreement did not make the siblings agree about everything; it gave them a method for making decisions and managing disagreementswhen they arise. By the following summer, the roof had been replaced, the expenses had been allocated, and the Fourth of July problem had been resolved through a rotating holiday schedule.
A family cabin is more than real estate, but at the end of the day, it is still real estate. Leaving it “equally to the children” may answer who owns it today, but thoughtful planning must also address how they will share it, how they will make decisions, who may own it tomorrow, and what happens when someone wants to leave.
Nicholas Mehlum is an attorney with Fryberger, Buchanan, Smith & Frederick, P.A., practicing in the areas of Business and Corporate law, Estate Planning, and Real Estate. This article is not intended to provide legal advice. You should always consult with an attorney about your specific circumstances.

